"A decisively unsentimental and honest entry in the queer cinema, PARIAH is here to stay".
Dee Rees’ debut feature, a coming-out drama expanding from her 2007 short of the same name, pivots on a 17-year-old Alike (Oduye, reprises the same role), an African-American girl maladroitly explores her inchoate sexuality against a stifling familial interference.
On paper, this précis is just like one of the numberless reiterations of its ilks, a bumpy journey of self-discovery, trepidation, excitement, and sorrow, mingled with temporal prejudice and religion-inflamed narrow-mindedness. But Dee Rees, against the story's well-trodden path (although, both her and Alike’s ethnic attributes give its story an edge of freshness), lends Alike’s bittersweet rite-of-passage a distinct flavor of probity and plausibility that refuses to sweet the pill.
Little doubt is cast on Alike’s self-identification as a lesbian, the meat of her day-to-day battle is with the world around her, and pointedly with her family, Audrey (Wayans), her God-bothering mother high-handedly reproves her inappropriate get-up and choice of friend, her bestie is Laura (Walker), an out-and-out butch, masking her crush by ushering Alike to the local lesbian haunts. It is not in the strobing nightspot where Alike tastes the forbidden fruit for the first time, but ironically, it is through Bina (Davis), her mother’s appointed friend, the daughter of her church-going coworker, Alike fully consummates her passion, yet the very next day, hits the rock bottom of a heartbreak, Bina's mood-swing is arguably, the weakest narrative linkage in the otherwise, slow-burned drama.
In due time, Alike’s baptism of fire will reach the boiling point in a seminal climax when she comes out during her parents’ escalating wrangle, the explosion is tempestuous and no easy reconciliation is attained afterward, but Alike, facilitated by her knack of writing, finally, she can throw off her guilt and secret, embrace a new lease on her life with resolution, she is "not running but choosing”, a sagacious war cry to heighten the requisite of having a choice, for those marginalized and nonconformist.
While Dee Rees and her DP Bradford Young grace the story with a raw, restive energy that best encapsulates Brooklyn’s milieu of black urban teenagers, Alike's story is sustained by its self-contained environs withexclusively non-whitecharacters, no racial tension is broached, homophobia is pandemic, in home and elsewhere, but a touching note is that among younger generations, acceptance becomes the normalcy.
A factoid might completely knock one’s socks off,Adepero Oduye is 33 when making this film and a further burrowing discovers that Aasha Davis, who plays her fellow high-schooler Bina, is born in 1973 (source from IMDb), it is sheer beggar belief that these actresses can pull off playing characters half their ages (a blessing bestowed to the race maybe), especially in the case of Oduye, animatedly effuses teen spirit and simmering angst in her breakthrough performance.
Among grown-ups there are also worthy players, although comparatively in a lesser extent, Charles Parnell (a younger-looking Keith David, anyone?) adeptly balances his benevolent father figure with his less savory image of a miffed and cheating husband as Arthur, Alike’s father; then Kim Wayans, the mega-villain in this shoestring production, is another monstrous mother figure in the spirit of Monique is Lee Daniels’ PRECIOUS (2009), less blustering but equally toxic and intractable.
A decisively unsentimental entry in the queer cinema and a resounding testing ground of Dee Rees’ acumen and auteurist disposition, PARIAH is here to stay.
referential films: Dee Rees’ MUDBOUND (2017, 8.1/10); Lee Daniels’ PRECIOUS (2009, 7.9/10).
虽然整个剧情仍旧没有走出同志题材的某种模式，家庭成员、社会环境、自我定位、情感纠葛，人物也不多，但是几个关键感情的点把握得很好，简单明了，一针见血，可能是和编导自身亲身经历不无关系。
最让人揪心的是母亲与Lee之间的关系，母亲的扮演者静水深流的表演真是滴水不漏。
普通的女孩，唠叨的母亲，沉稳如山的父亲，叠加在一起是看似普通的家庭，剥开表皮，内里却是支离破碎，父亲有情人，女儿是同性恋，母亲过分的爱让人窒息，上帝没有错误，是没有错误吗？听到女儿亲口说出，我是gay，母亲的野蛮爆粗，让女儿心里的伤痛完全撕开，我爱你，我走了，不是逃避，是选择。
我是你的孩子，永远是。
我不再是任何人的孩子，我是我。
"A decisively unsentimental and honest entry in the queer cinema, PARIAH is here to stay".
Dee Rees’ debut feature, a coming-out drama expanding from her 2007 short of the same name, pivots on a 17-year-old Alike (Oduye, reprises the same role), an African-American girl maladroitly explores her inchoate sexuality against a stifling familial interference.
On paper, this précis is just like one of the numberless reiterations of its ilks, a bumpy journey of self-discovery, trepidation, excitement, and sorrow, mingled with temporal prejudice and religion-inflamed narrow-mindedness. But Dee Rees, against the story's well-trodden path (although, both her and Alike’s ethnic attributes give its story an edge of freshness), lends Alike’s bittersweet rite-of-passage a distinct flavor of probity and plausibility that refuses to sweet the pill.
Little doubt is cast on Alike’s self-identification as a lesbian, the meat of her day-to-day battle is with the world around her, and pointedly with her family, Audrey (Wayans), her God-bothering mother high-handedly reproves her inappropriate get-up and choice of friend, her bestie is Laura (Walker), an out-and-out butch, masking her crush by ushering Alike to the local lesbian haunts. It is not in the strobing nightspot where Alike tastes the forbidden fruit for the first time, but ironically, it is through Bina (Davis), her mother’s appointed friend, the daughter of her church-going coworker, Alike fully consummates her passion, yet the very next day, hits the rock bottom of a heartbreak, Bina's mood-swing is arguably, the weakest narrative linkage in the otherwise, slow-burned drama.
In due time, Alike’s baptism of fire will reach the boiling point in a seminal climax when she comes out during her parents’ escalating wrangle, the explosion is tempestuous and no easy reconciliation is attained afterward, but Alike, facilitated by her knack of writing, finally, she can throw off her guilt and secret, embrace a new lease on her life with resolution, she is "not running but choosing”, a sagacious war cry to heighten the requisite of having a choice, for those marginalized and nonconformist.
While Dee Rees and her DP Bradford Young grace the story with a raw, restive energy that best encapsulates Brooklyn’s milieu of black urban teenagers, Alike's story is sustained by its self-contained environs withexclusively non-whitecharacters, no racial tension is broached, homophobia is pandemic, in home and elsewhere, but a touching note is that among younger generations, acceptance becomes the normalcy.
A factoid might completely knock one’s socks off,Adepero Oduye is 33 when making this film and a further burrowing discovers that Aasha Davis, who plays her fellow high-schooler Bina, is born in 1973 (source from IMDb), it is sheer beggar belief that these actresses can pull off playing characters half their ages (a blessing bestowed to the race maybe), especially in the case of Oduye, animatedly effuses teen spirit and simmering angst in her breakthrough performance.
Among grown-ups there are also worthy players, although comparatively in a lesser extent, Charles Parnell (a younger-looking Keith David, anyone?) adeptly balances his benevolent father figure with his less savory image of a miffed and cheating husband as Arthur, Alike’s father; then Kim Wayans, the mega-villain in this shoestring production, is another monstrous mother figure in the spirit of Monique is Lee Daniels’ PRECIOUS (2009), less blustering but equally toxic and intractable.
A decisively unsentimental entry in the queer cinema and a resounding testing ground of Dee Rees’ acumen and auteurist disposition, PARIAH is here to stay.
referential films: Dee Rees’ MUDBOUND (2017, 8.1/10); Lee Daniels’ PRECIOUS (2009, 7.9/10).